Trusted local news leader for Prescott area communities since 1882
Sat, Jan. 18

Scottsdale woman told officers she smothered 79-year-old mother, police say

Holly Brennan.(Scottsdale Police Department via AP)

Holly Brennan.(Scottsdale Police Department via AP)

SCOTTSDALE — A Scottsdale woman accused of smothering her elderly mother to death in their home admitted doing so during a call with a police dispatcher and had previously been arrested for threatening her, authorities said Tuesday.

Holly Brennan, 46, told Scottsdale police after her arrest that she had talked about killing her mother on social media in 2017, according to a probable cause statement.

Her comments later led to her arrest. Online records indicate Brennan faced misdemeanor charges in March 2017 in Scottsdale City Court for repeated acts of harassment and threatening or intimidating a victim.

Brennan also told police she had homicidal thoughts about her mother last year and tried to seek treatment.

Brennan, who is facing a second-degree murder charge, was taken into custody Monday after officers went to her apartment and found Sharon Simmons, 79, dead, said Sgt. Ben Hoster.

A judge on Tuesday ordered her held on $1 million bail and that a public defender be appointed to represent her.

The death was discovered after a neighbor called 911 at Brennan's request.

Hoster said the dispatcher pressed the neighbor for more information, and the neighbor handed the phone to Brennan who told the dispatcher "I killed my mom."

According to Hoster, Brennan told officers at the scene that she had smothered Simmons. The officers found Simmons lying on her back with her body partly on a bed. A pillow was partially covering her face.

When questioned by investigators, Brennan said she decided to kill her mother a few minutes earlier. She described straddling the woman and then smothering her using a pillow and her hand.

After the killing, Brennan said, she went to a convenience store and bought vodka and gin.

Event Calendar
Event Calendar link
Submit Event

This Week's Circulars

To view money-saving ads...